Reprioritize or Add People? A Simple Test for Banks

In my experience, when banks run short on project capacity, they try to fix it by hiring more people. If that doesn’t solve the problem, they bring in contractors or consultants. Sometimes, that’s exactly what’s needed. But usually, the people who could fix things are already there, just busy with less important work.

A quick project capacity test

Ask yourself if your current team could handle the job if you paused or stopped some of their other tasks. If the answer is yes, you should reprioritize instead of hiring more people.

There are two scenarios in which it's worth paying for outside assistance:

  • You don’t have the skills. If the work needs skills your bank doesn’t have and won’t need long term, it’s usually cheaper to bring in outside help than to develop those skills internally.
  • The need won’t last. It usually doesn’t make sense to hire someone permanently just to fill a short-term gap.

Most can’t clearly say how their people spend their time, so they have no real picture of their project capacity.

Choosing how the work gets done

Once leadership agrees on priorities, each project needs a delivery plan. Asking, "Can we do it ourselves?" is a good start, but it’s too narrow. The real question is which approach gives you the best mix of ownership, expertise, speed, and capacity for that project.

Model When It Makes Sense What to Watch
Internal The capability is strategic; you need people who know the bank, and you have the capacity You may not have enough of the right people
Consulting You need specialist expertise, an outside view, or to move faster Someone inside the bank still has to own it
Staff augmentation The strategy is set, and you just need extra hands or skills for a while The bank keeps control of direction and management
Hybrid You want to own the work but need outside expertise or capacity alongside your team Be clear about who does what and who decides

Decide what stays in-house

One bank we worked with had a clear transformation goal. The challenge was that it tried to deliver the transformation using the same people who handled daily operations.

Instead of hiring permanent staff, they divided the work into three groups. Some tasks stayed with their own people, some needed outside specialists, and the rest just needed temporary help.

The bank kept control of key decisions and knowledge, bringing in external help to speed things up. The project finished four months early, and they didn’t need to hire any permanent staff since it was always meant to be short term.

Sometimes it’s a governance problem

Often, what seems like a staffing shortage is a problem with how decisions and priorities are managed.

At one bank, several business and IT teams were running related projects. Each team set its own priorities and deadlines, and each reported to different people. Instead of adding more project managers, we put all the projects under one governance process. This clarified who made decisions and showed how the projects were connected. The leadership team could now see capacity and delivery risks all in one place.

Within a few weeks, leadership could spot conflicts while they were still small. This made it easier to shift people to the most important work, and project owners knew they were accountable. The bank gained more project capacity this way than it would have by hiring new staff.

When outside help is worth it

Here are two points at which banks usually need outside support:

  • First, strategy. This includes prioritizing initiatives, reviewing operating models, conducting cost and efficiency reviews, developing technology and digital strategy, planning M&A and conversion, and building transformation roadmaps.
  • Second, during delivery. This covers program leadership, process redesign, rescuing troubled projects, bringing in specialist skills, interim leaders, and extra delivery capacity.

The key with outside support is getting the resources you need, for only as long as you need them.

FAQs

How is Newbold different from big consulting or general staffing firms?
Do you only work in finance and mortgage?
What if we’re mid-project and behind?

Read the full white paper. Many Projects, Not Enough Capacity includes the C-suite test and measures that show whether your portfolio discipline is working.

Check your portfolio. Our 10-question Portfolio Capacity Checklist takes about five minutes and shows where your bank’s project capacity is most stretched.”

Posted in